Convenience stores push back against strict tobacco regulations

During a recent government meeting, the president of the New York Association of Convenience Stores addressed concerns regarding proposed local legislation aimed at regulating tobacco sales in Albany County. Representing over 10,000 small businesses, he expressed support for the intent of the legislation, which seeks to protect youth from tobacco products, but argued that its current framework could have detrimental effects on community retailers.

The speaker highlighted a key inconsistency in the proposed law: while it aims to limit access to tobacco for minors, it would grant preferential licensing to smoke shops, which often sell flavored vape products that appeal to underage consumers. He criticized the lack of enforcement against these retailers, suggesting that strengthening existing laws would be a more effective way to curb underage access to tobacco without penalizing compliant businesses.

Additionally, he raised concerns about a proposed 1,000-foot restriction on tobacco sales near schools, deeming it excessive compared to the 200-foot rule applied to alcohol sales. He argued that such a broad restriction could jeopardize established businesses without addressing illegal sales effectively.

The speaker also pointed out the complications arising from the inability to transfer tobacco licenses when a business is sold, which could devalue existing businesses and create unnecessary hurdles for new owners. He urged the county to consider a more balanced approach, similar to exemptions granted in other municipalities, such as Syracuse, which have allowed gas stations to operate under different regulations.

In closing, he reiterated the commitment of convenience stores to preventing youth smoking and called for a regulatory framework that protects both public health and the economic viability of local businesses. The public forum concluded with no further speakers.