In a recent government meeting, stakeholders voiced their concerns regarding proposed alterations to the historic Manufacturers Trust Company building at 510 Fifth Avenue, a designated individual and interior landmark in New York City. John Graham from the Victorian Society emphasized the importance of preserving the building's unique architectural features, particularly its transparency and original interior elements. He applauded the planned removal of a ground floor demising wall but urged for the restoration of the Bertoia sculpture wall to its original location, arguing that the proposed changes could detract from the building's celebrated transparency.

Graham also criticized the plans for two large LED signs, suggesting that their size and placement would obstruct views and undermine the building's historic character. He called for a reduction in the signage's dimensions and a reconfiguration of display units to maintain the landmark's integrity.

Liz Waitkus from DOCOMOMO US echoed these sentiments, highlighting the significance of the building's design and public access. She expressed concern over the rushed nature of the review process, advocating for better stakeholder engagement to prevent last-minute surprises, as had occurred during previous renovations. Waitkus reiterated that any signage should be minimal and secondary to the building's architectural elegance, aligning with the landmark's designation report from 1997.

The discussions reflect a broader commitment to preserving New York City's architectural heritage while navigating the challenges of modernization and commercial interests. The Landmarks Preservation Commission (LPC) is expected to consider these testimonies as they deliberate on the proposed changes to this iconic structure.