In a recent meeting, the Landmarks Preservation Commission reviewed a proposal for significant renovations at 12 East 69th Street, a Neoclassical townhouse located in the Upper East Side Historic District. The application, presented by preservation consultants and architects, seeks to restore the building's historic features while making necessary modifications to enhance its functionality.

Key elements of the proposal include replacing the existing entrance infill with a historically accurate wooden door, lowering the area way, and enlarging masonry openings. The project aims to return the entryway to its original proportions, which were altered in the mid-20th century. The proposed changes will also involve modifications to the rear facade and the construction of rooftop additions, including mechanical units and shade structures.

The commission heard supportive testimony from representatives of local preservation groups, including the Friends of the Upper East Side and the Victorian Society of New York. While both organizations expressed general approval of the facade restoration and the addition of a terrace garden, they raised concerns about the potential visual congestion created by the rooftop structures. The Victorian Society specifically noted that while the shade structures are in keeping with the district's character, a less crowded rooftop would be preferable.

Commissioners discussed the visibility of the proposed changes, particularly from public thoroughfares and adjacent alleyways. They acknowledged that while some elements, such as the rooftop bulkhead and shade structures, may be partially visible, they are designed to blend with the existing architectural context.

Ultimately, the commission voted unanimously in favor of the application, emphasizing that the proposed work would not detract from the building's historic character or that of the surrounding district. The approval marks a significant step towards restoring the townhouse to its former glory while accommodating modern needs.