In a recent government meeting, officials discussed the city's homeless encampment policy and enforcement actions, providing an update on the legal landscape surrounding these issues. City Attorney Calderon emphasized that the presentations were informational, aimed at clarifying the current state of municipal codes and recent court rulings rather than proposing solutions.
Calderon outlined existing municipal regulations that prohibit littering, overnight camping in public spaces, and obstruction of public pathways. These violations can lead to citations and clean-up actions. However, she noted that these provisions have been in place since before recent legal challenges, which have significantly impacted how cities manage homelessness.
The discussion highlighted a pivotal 2018-2019 Ninth Circuit ruling that deemed certain city ordinances unconstitutional under the Eighth Amendment, which protects against cruel and unusual punishment. This ruling arose from cases where individuals were penalized for sleeping outdoors without access to alternative shelter. The court's decision prompted cities to exercise caution in enforcing such ordinances, particularly during the COVID-19 pandemic when restrictions limited movement.
A recent Supreme Court ruling clarified that cities could enforce ordinances against specific actions, such as camping on public property, without violating constitutional rights, provided that these actions do not criminalize a person's status as homeless. This ruling has opened the door for cities to revisit their enforcement strategies.
Calderon also referenced a class-action lawsuit against Denver, which raised concerns about the treatment of personal property during encampment clean-ups. The case underscored the need for clear policies regarding notice and the handling of belongings, as improper management could lead to constitutional challenges.
The meeting concluded with a promise of further information from police department representatives, who are expected to provide insights into the city's current approach to managing homelessness and encampments. The discussions reflect ongoing efforts to balance enforcement with the rights and needs of vulnerable populations in the community.