During a recent government meeting, significant concerns were raised regarding a proposed Planned Unit Development (PUD) at 24 Cathedral Place in St. Augustine. The discussions highlighted the potential impacts of the project on the historic character of the area, pedestrian experience, and traffic management.

Dr. Leslie Keys, a local historian, emphasized that the proposed development's mass and scale are excessive, arguing that it does not align with the existing zoning regulations. He pointed out that the project would cover 100% of the lot, with balconies extending into the public right-of-way, which could disrupt the pedestrian experience. Keys also noted the lack of consideration for traffic flow and parking, particularly given the proximity to the Bridal Alliance, a known mobility challenge in the area.

Carl Halbert, a former city archaeologist, raised concerns about the archaeological implications of the project, stressing the importance of adhering to the city’s archaeological ordinance. He criticized the current fee structure for archaeological assessments, suggesting that the maximum fee of $25,000 is insufficient for a project of this magnitude, which could potentially disturb significant historical artifacts.

The meeting also featured testimony from Melinda Reconce, who urged the committee to consider past discussions and decisions regarding the site. The overall sentiment among speakers was one of caution, advocating for a thorough review of the project's design and its implications for the historic district.

As the city moves forward with the review process, the voices of concerned citizens and experts underscore the need for careful consideration of St. Augustine's unique historical context and the potential consequences of new developments in the area.