In a recent government meeting, the Historic Architectural Review Board (HARB) discussed a proposal for a roof replacement at a residential property located at 107 La Quinta Place, a contributing structure to the Lincolnville National Register Historic District. The current corrugated metal roof is set to be replaced with a standing seam metal roof, which the applicant argues is more durable and aesthetically pleasing than the traditionally approved 5V crimp metal roof.

Will Hester, representing Hester's Roofing and Coating, presented the case, emphasizing the longevity and reduced maintenance needs of the standing seam option. He noted that while the 5V crimp roof is the standard for such historic structures, the standing seam roof's design features—such as covered fasteners and a heavier gauge metal—would enhance the roof's durability and reduce the risk of leaks.

The board reviewed the architectural guidelines for historic preservation, which typically favor the 5V crimp design. However, Hester highlighted that the proposed standing seam roof would maintain the historic character of the building, particularly given its height and visibility from the street. He also pointed out that the neighborhood predominantly features asphalt shingle roofs, making the standing seam option a unique yet compatible choice.

Board members expressed concerns regarding the visual impact of the standing seam roof compared to the approved designs. However, they acknowledged the minimal difference in profile between the proposed and existing roofs, with some members indicating support for the application based on the standing seam's aesthetic and functional benefits.

The discussion concluded with the board considering the implications of the roof replacement on the historic integrity of the structure while weighing the practical advantages of the proposed materials. The board is expected to make a decision on the application in the coming weeks, reflecting on both the preservation of historic character and the need for modern, durable roofing solutions.