City Council Moves to Ban Short Term Rentals

The city of Mentor is addressing long-standing confusion surrounding short-term rentals, as officials clarify their zoning regulations. For nearly a decade, the administration has maintained that short-term rentals are not permitted in most areas of the city, with the exception of one zoning district—the planned development overlay—where they are allowed.

City officials acknowledged that many residents may not fully understand the nuances of zoning laws, which specify permitted uses rather than prohibiting specific activities. This has led to instances of residents mistakenly operating short-term rentals, believing them to be similar to traditional home rentals. The administration is now proposing a new regulation to explicitly state that short-term rentals are not allowed in Mentor, and the city council is considering whether to remove them as a permitted use in the planned development district.

Additionally, the council is reviewing an outdated provision in the zoning code that allows for the conditional rental of rooms in residential districts. This provision, which has not been actively utilized in over 20 years, is seen as archaic and is also under consideration for removal.

Short-term rentals are defined as transient guest room rentals, akin to hotel operations, but with fewer than five guest rooms. Unlike hotels, which are licensed and regulated by the state, short-term rentals in Mentor currently operate without such oversight, leading to further complications in enforcement and compliance.

The proposed changes aim to streamline the city's zoning regulations and eliminate confusion regarding short-term rentals and room rentals, ensuring clarity for residents and potential operators alike.