The Smith County Commissioner’s Court convened on September 17, 2024, with a quorum present, to discuss several agenda items, notably the appointment of a new Justice of the Peace for Precinct 5. The meeting began with an invocation and a reminder for public participation, allowing citizens to voice their opinions on agenda items.

Bob Brewer, a member of the public, addressed the court regarding the importance of constitutional knowledge for candidates being considered for the judicial position. He emphasized the need for appointees to demonstrate a strong understanding of the Constitution, citing a perceived crisis in legal adherence within the community. Brewer distributed copies of the Constitution to the candidates and expressed his belief that a solid grasp of constitutional principles is essential for those in public office.

Jay Brooks also spoke on the same agenda item, expressing gratitude for Judge Johnson's service and urging the court to consider the public's voice in the appointment process. Brooks highlighted his concern about the potential for the court to give an unfair advantage to candidates who intend to run for the position permanently. He argued that the decision should ultimately rest with the voters, advocating for transparency and public input before any appointments are made.

Brooks requested that the court table agenda item 16, which involved taking action following an executive session, to allow for further public discussion and feedback on the candidates. He stressed that this meeting represented a critical opportunity for the community to engage with the candidates and influence the selection process.

The court is expected to deliberate on these matters further, with public sentiment playing a crucial role in the decision-making process for the interim appointment.