In a recent government meeting, members of the Historic District Commission (HDC) engaged in a heated discussion regarding the potential demolition of a garage that is considered a significant part of the neighborhood's historic character. The meeting highlighted differing opinions on whether to approve the demolition or allow the structure to remain.

Commission members expressed strong sentiments against the demolition, emphasizing the garage's unique contribution to the streetscape. Abby Angus, Carrie, and Connie all voiced their opposition, arguing that the garage should not be removed as it plays a vital role in maintaining the historic integrity of the area. Angus noted that the structure meets the criteria for a contributing building, while Carrie pointed out that it is unusual for a new building to be approved before addressing the fate of an existing structure.

The discussion also touched on the implications of the garage's removal for future development. Members raised concerns about the potential impact on the streetscape and the historic Elm tree nearby. The consensus among the commissioners was clear: they would not support a demolition or even a relocation of the garage, insisting that it should remain in its current position.

The meeting concluded with a reminder that the decision would be based on the merits of the application presented, rather than any past approvals. The HDC's stance reflects a commitment to preserving the historical character of the neighborhood, even as the applicant indicated a willingness to appeal the decision if necessary.