Historic Door Replacement Sparks Controversy in Franklin

In a recent government meeting, the Historic Zoning Commission addressed two significant proposals concerning properties within the downtown Franklin Historic District.

The first item discussed was the proposed replacement of a compromised door at 108 Church Street, a residential unit within the Brownstones infill development. The existing arched double door, which has been causing internal damage due to leaks, is set to be replaced with a new door from the Renewal by Andersen line. While the new door will maintain a similar grid pattern, concerns were raised about it disrupting the existing architectural rhythm of the building. The commission ultimately decided to defer the decision until the next meeting on November 11, allowing the property owner to provide input, as is customary for such discussions.

The second proposal involved the installation of a white wooden picket fence at 1102 West Main Street, a property recognized as part of the Hincheyville National Register District. The fence, designed to be 36 inches high and composed of 8-foot sections, aims to enhance the property's aesthetic while providing safety for the owner's children and pets. The commission unanimously approved the fencing proposal, citing its compatibility with the historic character of the area.

These discussions reflect the commission's ongoing commitment to preserving the historical integrity of the district while accommodating the needs of property owners.