Homeowner proposes innovative roof solution after contractor woes

In a recent government meeting, officials discussed the ongoing roof replacement project at the historic William H. Weiss residence located in the Hamburg Local Landmark Historic District. The homeowner initially sought approval to replace the damaged French clay tile roof, which had been compromised during a severe storm in August 2020. However, challenges with contractors and high costs—over $400,000 for the clay tile replacement—led to a reconsideration of the project.

At the September 10 meeting, the homeowner proposed a more affordable asphalt shingle roof, estimated at $37,000. This request was tabled as officials encouraged the homeowner to explore alternative materials that would better match the original clay tile while remaining within budget. Following this guidance, the homeowner returned with a new proposal for a Brava Composite Spanish Barrel Tile roof in an antique clay color, designed to closely resemble the existing roof.

The composite material offers a modern solution, being lightweight and maintenance-free, which could ease shipping and installation costs. The commission is now reviewing this updated proposal, which aims to balance historical preservation with practical affordability for the homeowner.