During the La Crosse City Council meeting on December 9, 2024, significant discussions centered around proposed regulations for short-term rentals, particularly Airbnb properties. The proposed ordinance, which includes a minimum stay of seven days and a maximum of 180 days, has raised concerns among local homeowners and rental operators about its potential economic impact.

Several speakers voiced their opposition to the ordinance, arguing that it would make short-term rentals financially unviable. One resident highlighted that only nine out of eight properties met the proposed requirements, suggesting that the ordinance could force many Airbnb hosts to sell their properties or convert them into long-term rentals. This shift, they argued, would likely lead to increased rental prices, mirroring the high costs seen in new luxury apartment complexes in the area, which charge upwards of $1,200 for a one-bedroom unit.

Critics of the ordinance expressed that the intent to increase affordable housing supply is misguided, as the limited number of short-term rentals in the city would not significantly impact the overall housing market. They emphasized that imposing such restrictions could inadvertently benefit larger hotel chains at the expense of local homeowners, who rely on short-term rental income to manage their mortgages and maintain their properties.

Another speaker suggested that instead of a minimum stay requirement, the city should consider a licensing process to address concerns about short-term rentals. This approach would allow for better regulation without undermining the rights of homeowners to utilize their properties effectively.

The discussions reflect a broader concern about balancing the needs of the community, tourism, and the housing market. As the council considers these regulations, the implications for local residents and the economy remain a critical focus. The meeting underscored the importance of finding solutions that support both affordable housing initiatives and the livelihoods of those who depend on short-term rentals.