In a recent government meeting, discussions centered around a proposed addition to the historic Greenlee House, located within a designated National Register Historic District. The architectural review committee had previously met to evaluate the initial design, leading to revisions that were presented at the current meeting.
The proposed project includes a small bathroom addition on the north side and a larger addition at the rear of the house. The architectural review committee expressed that the revised plans align with the applicable guidelines and standards for historic preservation. However, concerns were raised regarding the choice of a metal roof for the new addition, with staff recommending a shingled roof to better match the existing structure.
The applicant, Matt Jones, explained that the decision to use a metal roof was influenced by the low slope required for the addition, which would not adequately drain if a shingle roof were used. He provided examples of other historic homes in the area that feature metal roofs, arguing that such materials are consistent with the architectural character of the neighborhood.
During the meeting, committee members acknowledged the challenges of adding to historic homes, particularly regarding maintaining the integrity of the original design. They noted that while the addition is small and positioned toward the rear, it is essential to ensure that any new construction respects the historic context.
Public comments were invited but none were received. Ultimately, the committee members expressed support for the proposed design, emphasizing that the roof's visibility from the street would be minimal due to its low slope. The meeting concluded with a consensus that the project meets the necessary standards for approval, pending further discussion on the roofing material.