Residents of Valley View, Texas, voiced strong opposition during a recent county commissioners' meeting regarding a proposed specific use permit (SUP) for a wine production facility at Lake Ray Roberts. Diane Staley, a long-time resident, emphasized the community's commitment to adhering to established planning and zoning regulations, which she argued are essential for maintaining the area's rural character. Staley highlighted concerns over the lack of a legitimate site plan submitted by the winery's owner, Chris, and pointed to previous violations, including the removal of trees along the shoreline.

Staley's remarks were echoed by other residents, including Kim Ross, who recounted her own struggles with a neighbor's business that violated zoning regulations. Ross asserted that the proposed winery expansion does not align with the agricultural zoning intended for the area, which primarily consists of farms and residential properties.

PJ Altschuler, another local resident, reinforced these sentiments, stating that the proposed facility contradicts the zoning plan adopted in 2019, which was designed to preserve the community's rural integrity. Altschuler urged the commissioners to uphold the zoning regulations to protect the quality of life for existing residents.

Conversely, supporters of the winery, including Laura McMullen, argued that the facility would benefit the local economy and align with agribusiness definitions recognized by the state. McMullen pointed out that the winery has contributed positively to the community, including disaster relief efforts following a recent tornado.

Chris Macintosh, the owner of the winery, defended the proposal, asserting that it falls within his rights as outlined by the Texas Department of Agriculture. He emphasized that the discussion should focus solely on the production facility and not on unrelated past proposals or personal grievances.

The meeting highlighted a significant divide within the community, with many residents advocating for strict adherence to zoning laws to preserve the rural landscape, while others see potential economic benefits in the winery's expansion. The commissioners are now faced with the challenge of balancing these competing interests as they consider the future of land use in the Lake Ray Roberts area.