During a recent government meeting, concerns regarding potential contamination from large-scale development in Sag Harbor were prominently discussed. Officials expressed fears that such projects could lead to significant environmental hazards, including the risk of costly remediation efforts if developers were unable to manage contamination issues, potentially resulting in bankruptcy and leaving the community with hazardous conditions.

The area in question, located west of Main Street, has a history of industrial use dating back to the 1800s, when it was filled in to create land for various operations, including railroad yards and a manufactured gas plant. These activities have historically posed risks of contamination through spills and improper waste disposal, long before the establishment of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).

Contamination issues have been documented since the 1990s, leading to a remediation plan agreed upon by National Grid and the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC). However, it was noted that contamination extends below the original wetland bed, prompting the decision to cap the remaining contaminated areas—a standard practice in environmental management.

In 2014, a site management plan was established for the affected properties, including 5 Bridge Street and parts of 11 Bridge Street. Notably, the previous owner of 11 Bridge Street granted an environmental easement that prohibits residential development on the site, a condition that remains binding and was transferred to the current developer upon purchase in late 2021.

The discussions highlighted the ongoing challenges of balancing development with environmental safety, emphasizing the need for stringent oversight to prevent potential public health risks in the community.