In a recent government meeting, the Carson City Board discussed the approval of a contract with Lloyd Consulting Group for the design of synthetic turf fields at John D. Winters Softball Field, with a budget not to exceed $238,405. The decision follows a recommendation from the Parks and Recreation Commission, which unanimously endorsed the use of artificial turf over natural grass after evaluating public feedback and maintenance considerations.

Parks Project Manager Nick Wentworth highlighted that synthetic turf would significantly increase available playing time and reduce maintenance demands, addressing complaints about the current poor condition of the fields. He noted that the majority of users favored the synthetic option, which provides a more consistent playing surface.

However, the proposal has sparked public concern regarding health and safety issues associated with synthetic turf, including potential injury risks, heat retention, and environmental impacts. Wentworth and Anthony Stevenson from Lloyd Consulting Group responded to these concerns, referencing an EPA study that indicated no significant difference in toxic exposure between synthetic and natural grass users. They emphasized that modern synthetic turf has improved safety features compared to older versions, which were linked to higher injury rates.

The board also discussed the financial implications of the project, including the need for a long-term maintenance plan for the synthetic fields. Jennifer Budge, Parks and Recreation Director, assured that funding strategies would be developed to ensure ongoing maintenance and replacement of the turf over time.

Additionally, the meeting touched on potential enhancements to the park, such as dugout improvements and shade structures, with a separate allocation of $1 million from the capital budget aimed at upgrading amenities at Centennial Park.

Despite the push for synthetic turf, some board members expressed skepticism, citing a preference for natural grass among professional leagues and the ongoing trend of major sports organizations transitioning back to grass fields. The discussion highlighted the complexities of balancing user preferences, safety, environmental concerns, and financial sustainability in the decision-making process for community sports facilities.