Residents of Garden City voiced strong opposition to a proposed development plan during a recent Monroeville Planning Commission meeting, raising concerns about traffic, environmental impact, and the potential disruption to their long-standing neighborhoods.

The proposed development, which aims to build 95 new homes, has sparked significant backlash from local residents who argue that the plan would increase traffic congestion on already narrow streets like Hazelnut, Quince, and Buttercup. One resident highlighted that the traffic study conducted for the project was flawed, failing to account for peak traffic times and the existing quiet nature of their neighborhood. Concerns were also raised about the placement of mailbox clusters, which could exacerbate traffic issues.

Another resident, Shar Milner, emphasized that the streets were originally designed as dead ends, and the opening of these roads would disrupt the safety and tranquility of the area. Milner presented a petition with 326 signatures from residents opposing the plan, urging the commission to reconsider the development's implications on their community.

In contrast, some community members supported the development, arguing that it would bring new families to the area, boost local businesses, and contribute to the tax base, which has suffered since the pandemic. Proponents pointed out that the new homes would help alleviate the aging housing stock in Garden City and provide modern amenities.

However, the meeting revealed a deep divide among residents, with many calling for a comprehensive reassessment of the traffic impact and environmental considerations before any decisions are made. Concerns about the developer's past legal issues and the lack of communication with residents further fueled the opposition.

As the planning commission continues to deliberate on the proposal, the voices of Garden City residents underscore the complexities of balancing development with community needs and safety.