Landmark proposal transforms historic home with modern design

In a recent government meeting, significant discussions centered around a proposed alteration to a residential property in the West Pearl Historic District. The revised design aims to address previous concerns regarding the building's mass and scale, with staff noting that the updated proposal now presents as a one-and-a-half-story structure rather than a two-and-a-half-story one.

Key architectural features of the proposal include traditionally scaled double-hung windows, vertical wood siding, and dormers along the roof slopes. The design has been adjusted to reflect the character of the historic district, with a focus on maintaining compatibility with existing structures. Notably, the size of the rear deck has been reduced, and the garage design has been modified to include two smaller doors instead of one large door.

Staff emphasized adherence to design guidelines, which dictate that roof forms, including dormers, should be secondary to the main roof and compatible with the historic context. The guidelines also stress the importance of window and door placement, encouraging designs that reflect the proportions and patterns found in the district. The proposed materials, including wood siding and a stone chimney, align with those historically used in the area.

During the meeting, board members raised questions about specific design elements, such as the width of dormers and the appropriateness of the proposed roof materials. The applicant responded positively to feedback from the board, highlighting modifications made to enhance the design's alignment with community standards.

The board is set to deliberate on the proposal, considering whether it meets the established standards for issuance of a landmark alteration certificate. The outcome of this deliberation will determine the future of the project, which aims to balance modern living needs with the preservation of the historic character of the neighborhood.