Residents of Chula Vista are facing a contentious situation regarding a historic outbuilding at 238 Second Avenue, as the city’s zoning department has ordered its demolition due to alleged noncompliance with setback rules. The property, which includes a 134-year-old Victorian house, a garage, and the outbuilding, is designated as a historic site and has been owned by the current residents for over 30 years.

The owners have requested a waiver for the setback rules, arguing that the outbuilding, built over half a century ago, has been part of their property without dispute until recent plans for solar power installation prompted city officials to take action. The zoning department cited two main issues: the absence of a building permit for the outbuilding and its proximity to property boundaries, which do not meet current regulations.

The owners contend that the property lines were established long before the current zoning laws were enacted, and they believe the city’s enforcement actions are unjust and abusive. They expressed disappointment over the situation, which they claim not only affects them but also their neighbors, who will be impacted by the demolition.

As the deadline for demolition approaches next month, the owners are seeking support from the community and have invited neighbors to voice their concerns regarding the city’s decision. The outcome of this case could set a precedent for how historic properties are treated under current zoning laws in Chula Vista.