Historic Building Facade Redesign Sparks Community Debate

In a recent meeting of the Historic Architectural Review Board (HARB), significant modifications to the design of a historic building's front facade were discussed, reflecting feedback from a previous meeting in May 2023. The revisions include a simplification of the columns and rails on the front porch, while retaining existing window and door features. Notably, a chimney that was previously approved for removal will now be preserved.

The board reviewed the updated design, which has already received approval from state authorities and is currently in the permitting process. Members expressed concerns about the architectural integrity of the building, particularly its historical significance related to the civil rights movement in St. Augustine. One board member emphasized the importance of maintaining the building's original character, arguing that the new design risks compromising its historical value.

The discussion also highlighted the need for clarity regarding changes made to the front elevation, with some members questioning whether the modifications adequately addressed previous concerns. The board ultimately agreed to approve a certificate for partial demolition, allowing the proposed changes to proceed.

In a separate agenda item, the board considered another application for partial demolition at a property on St. Francis Street, built between 1910 and 1917. This proposal includes the removal of a chimney, roof replacement, and changes to window configurations. Staff emphasized the importance of maintaining the building's historic character, particularly in the context of the Lincolnville neighborhood, which is recognized for its historical significance.

Public comments during the meeting raised concerns about the potential impact of these changes on the neighborhood's character and the building's status as a contributing structure to the National Register. The board is tasked with ensuring that any alterations align with preservation standards while accommodating the needs of property owners looking to restore and improve their historic homes.