Controversy Erupts Over Historic Brick Painting Regulations

In a recent government meeting, staff addressed ongoing concerns regarding the preservation of historic masonry in the context of a building application that included painting previously unpainted brick. The discussion highlighted the challenges associated with removing paint from historic brick without causing damage, emphasizing that methods like sandblasting and power washing can severely compromise the integrity of the brick.

Staff presented three options for the committee's consideration regarding the application. The first option would approve all aspects of the application, including the painting of the building and the removal of an awning. The second option would allow painting of the building while excluding the unpainted brick, contingent upon the applicant researching and providing documentation on paint removal methods. The third option would deny the painting of the unpainted brick while approving the other changes.

Additionally, the meeting touched on the recent survey conducted by the state historic preservation office, which determined that the area surrounding the Farmers Market is eligible for historic district designation. This designation, while not yet formally applied for, carries regulatory implications similar to being listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Concerns were raised about whether the proposed painting could jeopardize this eligibility, although staff noted that the impact of one building's changes on the overall district status is uncertain.

The committee was encouraged to weigh these options carefully, considering both the preservation of historic elements and the potential for future development in the area.