During a recent government meeting, discussions centered around the potential appointment of Dr. Phil Williams Van Hickman to the Muskegon Planning Commission. One member expressed strong support for Dr. Hickman, citing his extensive experience and commitment to community service as key factors in his favor over fellow candidate Lashay Simmons. The member emphasized that while Simmons is qualified, Hickman's background and willingness to serve set him apart.

However, the meeting also revealed a divide among members regarding the appointment. Another member voiced a preference for Simmons, highlighting concerns about Hickman's employment history, which included several short-term positions. This member acknowledged Hickman's recent home purchase as a positive sign of his intent to remain in the area but maintained that they were more comfortable with Simmons for the current appointment.

The meeting concluded with a motion to recommend Dr. Hickman to the city commission for consideration, although no formal appointments were made during this session. The discussion reflects ongoing deliberations about leadership and representation within the planning commission, underscoring the importance of experience and community ties in local governance.