In a recent government meeting, the Historic Architectural Review Board (HARB) discussed the proposed demolition of a historic residential building located at 66 Saragossa Street, part of the Bridal Land development. The structure, a one-and-a-half-story frame vernacular residence built between 1904 and 1910, is recognized as a contributing property to the National Register Historic District.
The applicant, Jason Stantzel, presented a case for the total demolition of the building to make way for a new single-family home. As part of the application process, Stantzel provided documentation regarding the existing structural condition of the building and argued that economic hardship justified the demolition.
HARB staff reviewed the application and noted that the board must determine whether the provided documentation sufficiently supports the claim of undue economic hardship. They outlined potential actions for the board, including allowing the applicant more time to submit additional information or exploring incentives like the Avalon tax exemption program to make rehabilitation more feasible.
If the board finds the evidence satisfactory, they may approve the demolition with specific conditions. These include requirements for the salvage and preservation of significant building materials and architectural details for reuse in other historic properties, as well as ensuring that no demolition permit is issued until all necessary plans for the new construction are submitted.
The meeting highlighted the ongoing tension between development and historic preservation, as the board weighs the economic implications against the value of maintaining the area's historical integrity.