During a recent government meeting, community members voiced strong concerns regarding the demolition of the historic property at 11 Bridge Street, emphasizing the need for better preservation policies in St. Augustine. Melinda Ricansi, a local resident, highlighted the building's historical significance and criticized the decision to demolish it, arguing that it could have been saved and repurposed as a bed and breakfast. She pointed out that the property was not a public safety risk and called for stricter enforcement of the property maintenance code adopted in 2018 to prevent similar losses in the future.

Ricansi urged city officials to consider the qualifications of building inspectors, suggesting that a background in historic preservation could help avoid future demolitions of valuable properties. She stressed the importance of setting clear policies to protect St. Augustine's historic resources, comparing the city's preservation efforts to those of Savannah and Charleston.

Leslie Keys echoed Ricansi's sentiments, questioning the decision-making process that led to the demolition approval. She referenced past inspections that indicated the building was stable and criticized the reliance on a single report that favored demolition. Keys also called for transparency in the decision-making process and urged the commission to implement the property maintenance code effectively.

Chris Fulmer added to the discussion by drawing parallels between the situation at 11 Bridge Street and other historic buildings in the area, suggesting that some owners may be allowing their properties to deteriorate intentionally to facilitate demolition. He urged the commission to impose consequences for neglecting historic buildings.

The meeting underscored a growing demand among residents for stronger preservation measures and accountability in the management of historic properties, reflecting a community deeply invested in maintaining its cultural heritage.