Preservationists clash over historic home renovations in Princeton

In a recent government meeting, discussions centered around the preservation of historic homes on Alexander Street in Princeton, highlighting the importance of maintaining original architectural features while addressing modern energy efficiency needs.

Residents and preservation experts voiced concerns about proposed renovations that could compromise the integrity of these historic structures, which date back to the Greek Revival period. Speakers emphasized the significance of preserving original materials, such as window sashes and siding, arguing that these elements are crucial to understanding the craftsmanship and historical context of the buildings. Clifford Zink, a local resident with a background in historic preservation, stressed that removing original features would erase the buildings' historical narrative and diminish their cultural value.

The conversation also touched on the technical aspects of renovation, with experts suggesting that restoring existing windows and using interior storm windows could enhance energy efficiency without sacrificing historical authenticity. They argued that modern replacements, which often utilize simulated divided lights and aluminum trim, do not align with the spirit of preserving the historic fabric of the neighborhood.

The applicant's representatives acknowledged the challenges of balancing preservation with the need for energy efficiency, particularly in light of lead paint concerns and the necessity for improved insulation. They proposed a plan that includes maintaining original siding while potentially replacing windows on the side facades to facilitate better insulation and maintenance.

As the meeting concluded, there was a consensus on the need for a comprehensive conditions assessment of the buildings to guide future preservation efforts. The community remains engaged in the dialogue, advocating for a careful approach that honors Princeton's architectural heritage while accommodating contemporary living standards.