In a recent government meeting, discussions centered around the proposed reconstruction of a historic outbuilding that was severely damaged during a storm. The applicant, represented by Frank Nola, outlined plans to rebuild the structure while maintaining its exterior appearance, with some modifications to the window design.
The proposed changes include the addition of a circular window on the first floor and a large two-story window on the north side, which has raised concerns among commission members regarding the historical integrity of the building. Staff assessments emphasized the importance of adhering to historical guidelines, noting that the new windows should be in scale with the building's original design, which dates back to circa 1836.
Commission members expressed mixed feelings about the proposed modifications. While some acknowledged the need for light and space in the new design, others argued that the large window would disrupt the building's historical character, particularly since it is highly visible from the street. Suggestions were made to consider smaller, more proportionate windows that would align better with the building's original elevation.
The homeowner, Mrs. Ainsworth, defended the proposed design, highlighting the desire to create a more open and functional space while honoring the building's historical context. She noted that the previous structure had low ceilings and cramped spaces, and the intention was to enhance the quality of the living area.
The discussion underscored the delicate balance between preserving historical aesthetics and accommodating modern needs. As the commission deliberates on the proposal, the outcome will likely set a precedent for future renovations of historic structures in the area. The meeting concluded with a call for further consideration of the design elements to ensure they respect the building's historical significance while allowing for necessary updates.