Heritage tree removal sparks heated zoning board debate

In a recent government meeting, the Highland Park Zoning Board addressed the contentious issue of a heritage tree removal request at 953 Judson Avenue. The petitioners, Dean and Leslie Bradshaw, are seeking permission to remove a 36-inch white oak tree, citing concerns about its proximity to their home and potential structural impacts.

The discussion, which was a continuation from a previous meeting held on July 18, included a presentation by Patrick, who provided updated photographs and details about the tree's location and health. A certified arborist's memo confirmed that the tree is in good health but noted that its growth could pose future risks to the property, as it is currently situated just over three feet from the residence. The arborist projected that the tree could grow approximately half an inch annually, potentially encroaching further into the space needed for a compliant stair and landing.

Despite the Bradshaws' concerns, the forestry department has expressed opposition to the removal, reiterating their stance from earlier communications. They maintained that the materials submitted by the applicants did not present any new arguments to warrant a change in their position.

The meeting also introduced a new check-in policy for those providing testimony, requiring them to submit their information for follow-up on case results. The board is expected to deliberate on the application based on the standards outlined in Chapter 94 of the Highland Park Code. The outcome of this case could set a precedent for future tree removal requests in the area, highlighting the balance between property rights and environmental preservation.