Planning Commission set to approve historic restoration project

In a recent meeting of the Sierra Madre Planning Commission, discussions centered around a proposed project involving the restoration of a historic property, which has garnered attention for its adherence to preservation standards. The applicant has chosen a moire black finish for the project, which includes significant structural improvements to the roof, replacing cedar plank sheathing with solid sheathing.

Satflo's Environmental conducted a design review, confirming that the project aligns with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties. The review specifically highlighted compliance with standards 1, 2, and 5, which pertain to the preservation of the property's historical integrity.

The commission was reminded of the regulatory framework governing such projects, including the Sierra Madre Municipal Code and the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). Under these regulations, any alterations to historic landmarks that affect their exterior appearance require a certificate of appropriateness from the commission. The findings necessary for approval include ensuring that the work does not compromise the architectural significance of the landmark.

The proposed project involves the reconstruction of historic elements, such as chimneys and roof structures, using materials that are sympathetic to the original Craftsman style. The work has been evaluated by a qualified architectural historian, affirming its compliance with rehabilitation guidelines.

The commission has the option to approve the application, issue a certificate of appropriateness, or deny it based on findings that would prevent approval. Staff recommended approval of the application, emphasizing that the project qualifies for categorical exemptions under CEQA, which would streamline the approval process.

The meeting concluded with an invitation for the applicant to present their case, highlighting the collaborative nature of the planning process and the importance of community input in preserving Sierra Madre's historical assets.