Beach Theater Restoration Plan Aims to Revive Historic Charm

In a recent government meeting, the Historic Preservation Board discussed a certificate of appropriateness for the Beach Theater, a local historic landmark located at 315 Quarry Avenue. The theater, which was landmarked last June, has undergone ownership changes and is currently undergoing interior renovations. The new owners are seeking approval for significant exterior improvements, including the replacement of a deteriorating window wall system originally installed in 1970.

The proposed renovations aim to restore the theater's facade to its historical appearance, including the reinstallation of five illuminated signs that have been stored away. However, the current regulations only permit three illuminated signs on the exterior, prompting the need for a variance from the Board of Adjustment to allow for the historical illumination of all five signs.

During the meeting, board members reviewed historical photographs and discussed the significance of the signage and facade in preserving the theater's character. The staff recommended approval of the certificate of appropriateness, asserting that the proposed changes align with the City of St. Pete Beach Land Development Code and the Secretary of the Interior's standards for historic properties.

Architect Brit Hayes, representing the new owners, clarified that the renovation plans include replacing the existing window wall with two solid doors that reflect the original design of the theater. The new doors will be impact-rated and designed to minimize light exposure in the lobby area, consistent with historical aesthetics.

The board's discussions highlighted the importance of maintaining the theater's historical integrity while accommodating modern safety standards. The proposal is set to move forward, pending the necessary approvals for the illuminated signage.