Historic landmark faces demolition amid preservation debate

In a recent meeting of the Historic Preservation Board, discussions centered around the deteriorating condition of a residential structure located at 20 311 Pasagrill Way, which is a contributing landmark to the Pasagril National Register Historic District. The board reviewed a request for a certificate of appropriateness for demolition, as the property has been plagued by significant structural issues, including plumbing failures and water intrusion during rainstorms.

Staff members recommended approval for the demolition permit, emphasizing that such permits for contributing structures cannot be issued without prior approval of a Certificate of Appropriateness (CoA). The board has the authority to impose a 30-day hold on the demolition to explore preservation alternatives and incentives with the property owner.

The applicant, Jens Johnson, expressed his concerns regarding the building's condition, detailing extensive efforts to repair the structure, which have proven ineffective against pervasive rot and flooding. He noted that water has reached up to two inches inside the house during heavy rains, raising concerns about the feasibility of rehabilitation. Johnson also mentioned that elevating the building would require significant alterations that would compromise its original architectural integrity.

The board is tasked with considering various factors before granting demolition approval, including the building's historical significance, its contribution to the district's character, and the economic viability of rehabilitation efforts. The meeting highlighted the delicate balance between preserving historical architecture and addressing the practical challenges posed by deteriorating structures. Further discussions are anticipated as the board continues to evaluate the case and the potential for preservation.