Homeowners Clash Over Controversial Garage and Bedroom Addition

During a recent government meeting, the board reviewed an application for a significant residential project involving the conversion of an existing garage into a bedroom and the construction of a new garage with an in-law suite above it. The applicant, David Maleka, presented the proposal, emphasizing that the design aligns with the existing architecture of the house and meets the necessary criteria for placement on the lot.

The board clarified its role, stating that it would focus solely on the architectural aspects of the project, while the Board of Zoning and Planning (BZAP) would handle any variance requests. The proposed addition aims to enhance accessibility for aging residents, featuring a ground-floor master suite and a two-car garage with an upstairs living space.

However, the proposal faced scrutiny from neighboring property owner Brett Hoffman, who expressed concerns about privacy due to the planned seven windows overlooking his property. Hoffman highlighted that the new design could significantly alter the ambiance and privacy of his home, particularly as the garage would encroach on the setback line. He urged the applicant to reconsider the placement of the rear windows to maintain the current level of seclusion.

The board acknowledged Hoffman's concerns and noted that this meeting was just the initial step in the approval process, with further discussions scheduled for a future date. The outcome of this application will depend on the board's recommendations and the subsequent review by BZAP.