In a recent government meeting, discussions centered around proposed modifications to pool installations at two properties on Mariner Way, raising concerns about their visibility and appropriateness within the historic district.

The first application involved a pool at 2 Mariner Way, which was initially approved in March 2023. The applicant, Paul Santos from Nantucket Surveyors, presented a revised plan that elevates the pool within the deck by approximately 24 inches and reduces its size from 11 by 18 feet to 7 by 12.6 feet. The board expressed concerns regarding the height of the pool and its visibility from public ways, with several members questioning whether the proposed American Holly screening would adequately conceal the structure.

Commissioner Holly emphasized the need for robust, year-round vegetation to effectively screen the pool, while other board members noted that the elevated design could disrupt the historic character of the area. Public comments reflected opposition from neighbors, who argued that the pool's height and the proposed landscaping were incompatible with the neighborhood's aesthetic. Ultimately, the board voted to deny the modification, citing concerns about visibility and the appropriateness of the design.

The second application for 4 Mariner Way similarly sought to elevate a pool within a deck. While the board acknowledged the landscaping plan included a mix of native plants, concerns were raised about the potential visibility of the pool from Washington Street Extension. Board members suggested that a more organic arrangement of vegetation would be necessary to maintain the area's historic character.

As discussions progressed, the board reiterated the importance of ensuring that any modifications align with the historic district's standards. The meeting concluded with a call for more comprehensive plans in future applications, emphasizing the need for clarity on elevations and visual impacts.