Bonita Springs Council urges preservation of historic school amid demolition plans

The Lee County School District is facing significant community pushback regarding plans to demolish the historic Bonita Springs Elementary School, a building that has stood since 1921 and is the only property in the area listed on the National Registry of Historic Places. During the School Board Action Meeting on December 10, 2024, representatives from the Bonita Springs City Council, including Councilman Nigel Fullick, voiced their concerns about the decision to demolish the entire structure, which they believe is a vital part of the community's heritage.

Fullick highlighted the importance of the school as a historical landmark, noting that it serves as a tangible reminder of the city's past. He expressed disappointment over the lack of communication from the school board, stating that city officials were led to believe they could discuss the matter in a public workshop. However, a recent letter from the school board confirmed that the demolition plan would proceed without further consultation.

The councilman emphasized that while the building requires extensive repairs, estimated at around $68 million, the community is eager to collaborate with the school district to preserve a portion of the structure, particularly the south facade. He urged the board to consider a compromise that would honor the building's historical significance while addressing the practical needs of the school.

In addition to Fullick's remarks, Alexander P. Grant, a member of the Bonita Springs Historical Board, also spoke at the meeting. He shared his expertise in pest control and highlighted concerns about termite damage affecting the building. Grant's insights added another layer to the discussion about the feasibility of restoration versus demolition.

The meeting underscored the tension between preserving historical sites and the need for modern educational facilities. As the school board moves forward with its plans, the community remains hopeful for a resolution that respects both the past and the future of education in Bonita Springs. The outcome of this situation will likely have lasting implications for the community's identity and its contributions to the school district's funding.