Upper Lake residents voice concerns over industrial project on prime agricultural land

The Planning Commission Meeting held on December 12, 2024, in Lake County, California, focused on significant community concerns regarding a proposed industrial project on prime agricultural land. The meeting featured a series of public comments that highlighted issues related to noise, air quality, and environmental impacts.

The session began with residents expressing their worries about the potential noise levels from the project, which were not included in the initial decibel map. Community members emphasized the importance of understanding how the project would affect air quality, particularly given the proximity of sensitive areas such as a mobile home park and a preschool. One resident noted that this was the first time air quality had been addressed in discussions about the project, despite repeated requests for an emissions report since June.

Concerns were raised about the use of biomass materials, including questions about the presence of fire retardants and the testing of chemicals involved in the process. Residents argued that the location of the project, situated near a high-speed area of Highway 20, posed significant traffic risks and was unsuitable for industrial development. They urged the commission to reconsider the site, citing its pristine condition and wildlife habitat.

Another speaker criticized the project for being incompatible with the agricultural zoning of the land, pointing out the global food insecurity crisis and the need to protect prime agricultural areas. They raised alarms about the potential carcinogenic effects of biochar, a product associated with the project, and the flooding risks based on outdated FEMA flood maps.

In response to these concerns, a representative from the project clarified that the site was outside the flood zone and emphasized the benefits of biochar for agriculture. They also addressed the scenic highway regulations, stating that the project would not significantly impact the view due to its distance from the highway.

The meeting concluded with a call for further research and consideration of alternative locations for the project, as community members expressed a strong desire to protect their environment and ensure the safety of local residents. The commission is expected to review the feedback and assess the implications of the proposed project in light of the community's concerns.