The Phoenix City Public Safety and Justice Subcommittee convened on December 4, 2024, to address critical issues regarding fire station placements and emergency response times in the city. The meeting, led by Chairman Robinson, featured discussions primarily focused on the challenges faced by District 2, particularly concerning Fire Station 56 and the surrounding areas.

The meeting began with a presentation on the necessity of establishing a new fire station near TSMC, which is expected to alleviate response times for emergencies in that growing area. However, Councilman Waring raised concerns about the implications for District 2 residents, who may feel underserved despite their tax contributions. He emphasized that while new infrastructure is being developed, it does not necessarily improve service for his district, which has historically experienced longer response times.

Waring articulated the frustrations of District 2 residents, questioning the effectiveness of the current emergency response system. He pointed out that despite the addition of two new ambulances, the overall response times in his district may not improve significantly. He expressed skepticism about the assurances provided by city officials, noting that residents have been waiting for improvements for decades without substantial change.

In response, Chief Price outlined the criteria used for determining fire station placements, which include travel time, population density, and future growth projections. He acknowledged the interconnectedness of the emergency services network, stating that improvements in one area could benefit the overall system. However, Waring remained unconvinced, urging for more concrete data on how response times would improve with the new resources.

The meeting concluded with a commitment from city officials to provide further information and clarity on the issues raised, particularly regarding the distribution of emergency services and the rationale behind current infrastructure decisions. The subcommittee aims to address these concerns in future meetings, ensuring that all districts receive equitable emergency services.