Wyoming rancher raises alarm over risks of proposed Alkali Dam project

This article was created by AI using a video recording of the meeting. It summarizes the key points discussed, but for full details and context, please refer to the video of the full meeting. Link to Full Meeting

The Select Water Committee of the Wyoming Legislature convened on December 19, 2024, to discuss the contentious Alkali Dam project, which has raised significant concerns among local ranchers and stakeholders. The meeting highlighted the potential risks and financial implications of the proposed dam, particularly for those living downstream.

One of the most vocal opponents was ranch owner Mr. Gardner, who expressed deep apprehension about the safety and economic viability of the Alkali Dam. He drew parallels to historical dam failures, notably the catastrophic Teton Dam breach in 1976, which resulted in extensive damage and loss of life. Gardner emphasized that the current project, which is projected to cost taxpayers significantly more than initially estimated, primarily benefits a small group of irrigators—only 33 individuals—while placing the broader community at risk.

Gardner's testimony underscored the alarming increase in project costs, which have ballooned from an initial estimate of $35 million to $113 million due to unforeseen geological challenges. He questioned the rationale behind using taxpayer money to subsidize a project that offers minimal return on investment and disproportionately benefits a select few. He also raised concerns about the lack of accountability from the irrigators, who have not committed to covering the increased costs.

The meeting also featured testimonies from other stakeholders, including ranchers who voiced their frustrations over the tactics used to secure easements for the dam. Some ranchers reported feeling threatened by the prospect of eminent domain, which has fostered distrust and resentment towards the project. Mr. Sheeran, another ranch owner, echoed these sentiments, stating that the proposed reservoir would not benefit those living above it and criticized the negotiation tactics employed by the Norwood Water District.

The committee's discussions revealed a growing divide between the interests of local ranchers and the objectives of the water management authorities. As the meeting concluded, the future of the Alkali Dam project remained uncertain, with calls from ranchers for a reevaluation of its feasibility and a redirection of funds to more beneficial projects for the community.

The implications of this meeting are significant, as the committee must weigh the potential risks of the dam against the needs and safety of the local population. The ongoing dialogue will be crucial in determining the project's fate and ensuring that the interests of all stakeholders are adequately represented.

Converted from Select Water Committee, December 19, 2024-AM meeting on December 20, 2024
Link to Full Meeting