Architectural Board Rejects Controversial Addition to Historic Property Next to Country Club

The Historic Preservation Board of Coral Gables convened on December 20, 2024, to discuss significant modifications proposed for a residential property adjacent to a country club. The meeting focused on the architectural changes planned for the house, particularly an addition that would alter the front elevation and overall aesthetic of the structure.

The discussion began with board member concerns regarding the impact of the proposed addition on the unique characteristics of the house. One member expressed strong reservations, stating that the changes would detract from the property's distinctive chimney and overall profile. This member emphasized that the addition, while intended to be seamless, fundamentally altered the house's appearance and was not a positive enhancement.

Another board member, Mr. Garcia Ponce, offered a contrasting perspective. He noted that the property's proximity to a civic use area, rather than another residential property, made the proposed changes more acceptable. He argued that the addition would have a lesser impact on the neighborhood due to its location next to the country club and an alley.

The board continued to deliberate on the design elements, particularly the number of arches in close proximity, which some members found visually overwhelming. The discussion highlighted a divide among board members regarding the balance between preserving the historical integrity of the property and accommodating modern modifications.

As the meeting progressed, members acknowledged the complexity of the decision, weighing the architectural merits against the potential benefits of the proposed changes. The board ultimately aimed to reach a consensus that respected the historical significance of the property while considering its functional needs.

The meeting concluded with a commitment to further review the proposal, ensuring that all perspectives were considered before making a final decision. The board's next steps will involve additional discussions and possibly a site visit to better assess the implications of the proposed modifications.