San Antonio's City Council meeting on December 12, 2024, sparked heated discussions surrounding the proposed phase-out of horse-drawn carriages, a topic that has divided public opinion and raised concerns among local business owners.

Mark White, a prominent local business owner and grandson of the founder of Lone Star Carriage Company, voiced strong opposition to the proposal. He criticized the council for scheduling a special session to discuss the phase-out on the same day the results of a comprehensive study were presented. White argued that the study did not support the reasons for the ban and questioned the council's decision-making process. He highlighted potential conflicts with Texas state law, which recognizes horse-drawn carriages as vehicles and prohibits local governments from enacting stricter regulations than state law. White expressed concern that the council's actions could set a dangerous precedent for local businesses, suggesting that arbitrary decisions could threaten other lawful industries in the future.

In contrast, Mariah Smith, a leading activist advocating for the ban, presented a different perspective. She emphasized the overwhelming public support for transitioning away from horse-drawn carriages, citing a city-created survey that garnered over 47,000 responses. Smith argued that the survey results clearly indicated a majority preference for phasing out the carriages, framing the initiative as a reflection of evolving public sentiment.

The meeting underscored the tension between preserving traditional practices and addressing modern concerns about animal welfare and public safety. As the council weighs the implications of their decision, the outcome could significantly impact both the local economy and the cultural landscape of San Antonio. The council's next steps will be closely watched by both supporters and opponents of the proposed ban, as the debate continues over the future of horse-drawn carriages in the city.