New Orleans Council denies demolition of historic 1850s Treme cottage amid preservation efforts

The New Orleans Historic District Landmarks Commission convened on December 16, 2024, to discuss several key agenda items, including new business related to demolition applications. The meeting focused on the application for the demolition of a significant two-story residential building located at 1016 North Roman Street.

The applicant for this demolition is the City of New Orleans Department of Code Enforcement. The building in question is notable as it is the only remaining 19th-century structure on its block and holds historical significance within the Treme Historic District. Constructed around 1850, this three-bay Creole cottage features wood weatherboards and a stucco front facade, along with decorative elements such as window cornices and a central dormer.

During the discussion, it was noted that the overall condition of the building is poor, having only been visually inspected from the public right of way, as staff did not have access to the interior. Although the building is not in an active state of collapse, it has been boarded up over the years to prevent further deterioration.

The staff report indicated that no alternatives to demolition had been explored, and while the building's restoration would be challenging, it is not deemed beyond rehabilitation. As of October 1, 2024, a certificate of review was issued to allow the applicant to secure the building, with the expectation that it may eventually be restored.

In conclusion, the staff recommended denial of the demolition application, emphasizing the building's historical importance and potential for rehabilitation. The commission's decision on this matter will be crucial in preserving the architectural heritage of the Treme Historic District.