The St. Joseph County Commissioners convened on November 13, 2024, to discuss several agenda items, with a significant focus on a variance request for a sign at a local hotel. The meeting began with staff recommendations regarding the reconstruction of a pole sign that had been damaged in a recent storm.

The staff presented a detailed analysis of the proposed sign, noting that it would be placed in the same location as the original sign, which has been in existence since before 1970. The new sign is designed to comply with local ordinances, measuring 32 square feet and standing approximately 12 feet tall, both of which are within the allowable limits. The staff concluded that the approval of the variance would not be injurious to the public and would maintain the character of the area, as similar signs are common along State Road 933.

During the discussion, a letter of remonstrance was introduced, expressing concerns from neighboring businesses about the size of the proposed sign. Salam Othman, representing EAM Enterprises, voiced opposition, arguing that the sign's size could obstruct visibility for nearby businesses and negatively impact their operations. He requested that the sign either be reduced in size or moved further back from the road.

The petitioner, Jigar Patel, responded by stating that the new sign would be similar in size to the previous one and would not obstruct visibility for other businesses. He emphasized that the sign's placement was necessary for maintaining business visibility.

After public comments, the commissioners deliberated on the matter. A motion was made to approve the variance with conditions that all existing freestanding signs be removed and that the new sign be placed in the same location as the original. The motion was seconded and unanimously approved by the commissioners.

In conclusion, the commissioners granted the variance for the hotel sign, with the stipulation that it must adhere to the discussed conditions, ensuring that the sign's placement aligns with community standards and addresses the concerns raised by neighboring businesses. The meeting highlighted the balance between business interests and community aesthetics in local governance.