Santa Clara County Board debates ban on artificial turf citing health and environmental concerns

In a heated session at the Santa Clara County Board of Supervisors meeting on January 28, 2025, community members passionately voiced their opinions on a proposed ban of artificial turf on county-owned properties. The debate highlighted a deep divide between advocates for environmental health and those concerned about access to recreational spaces for youth.

As the meeting unfolded, speakers from various backgrounds took to the podium, sharing personal stories and expert opinions. Fad Khan, president of the Santa Clara County Medical Association, emphasized the environmental benefits of natural grass, citing its ability to recharge groundwater and sequester carbon. He urged the board to support an ordinance prohibiting new artificial turf, arguing that plastic surfaces contribute to harmful runoff and greenhouse gas emissions.

Conversely, supporters of artificial turf, including parents and youth sports coaches, expressed their fears that banning turf would exacerbate the already critical shortage of playing fields in the county. Malia Gunkoff, a synthetic turf consumer, shared how turf provided a safe space for her stepdaughter to play soccer year-round. Ricardo, a turf industry veteran, warned that the ban would negatively impact thousands of lives, particularly those of children who rely on these fields for physical activity.

The emotional testimonies continued, with some speakers highlighting the potential health risks associated with artificial turf, including heat-related injuries and exposure to toxic chemicals. Doctor Angela Bymaster pointed out that access to sports fields is crucial for combating health issues like obesity and mental health problems among low-income youth. In contrast, others argued that natural grass fields are often poorly maintained and can lead to injuries due to uneven surfaces.

The board members listened intently as the public comment period drew to a close, with over 100 speakers contributing to the discussion. The meeting underscored the complexity of balancing environmental concerns with the need for accessible recreational spaces, particularly for vulnerable communities. As the board prepares to make a decision, the outcome could significantly impact the future of youth sports and environmental policy in Santa Clara County.