Cochise County Board discusses legal strategy on jail construction lawsuit

Cochise County officials convened a special meeting on February 7, 2025, to discuss a significant legal matter concerning the county's ongoing jail district appeal. The meeting, held in the Board of Supervisors executive conference room, was accessible to the public both in-person and online, adhering to Arizona's open meeting laws.

The primary focus of the session was a motion to enter executive session for legal advice regarding a pending lawsuit involving Cochise County and a plaintiff, Daniel LaChance. The board unanimously agreed to move into executive session to discuss the implications of the case currently before the Arizona Supreme Court.

During the executive session, the board deliberated on the merits of LaChance's lawsuit, which raises concerns about the legality of a tax used to fund the construction of a new jail. Board members expressed their belief that the jail must be built, but acknowledged that there were valid points raised by LaChance, particularly regarding the disenfranchisement of voters in the tax approval process.

After thorough discussion, the board decided to withdraw their petition for review, signaling a willingness to explore a compromise with LaChance. This decision reflects a recognition of the need to address community concerns and ensure that all constituents feel their voices are heard in the decision-making process.

The board's commitment to building the jail remains firm, but they are now open to negotiating a resolution that could satisfy both the county's needs and the concerns raised by LaChance. This approach aims to foster a collaborative environment moving forward, potentially leading to a settlement that benefits all parties involved.

As Cochise County navigates this legal challenge, the board's actions underscore their dedication to transparency and community engagement, ensuring that the voices of residents are considered in critical decisions affecting the future of the county.