A proposed Fairfield Inn hotel in Oakdale has sparked a heated debate among city council members and residents, highlighting the community's struggle between growth and maintaining its small-town charm. During the December 4 city council meeting, discussions centered around the potential impact of the new hotel on local businesses and the overall character of Oakdale.

Supporters of the hotel argue that it could attract visitors and generate much-needed tax revenue, with one resident noting that over 9 million cars pass by the area annually. They believe that having a hotel option would prevent residents from traveling to nearby cities like Modesto for accommodations. "Not everyone will be able to stay in this hotel, but some will appreciate the option," one supporter stated, emphasizing the need for diverse lodging options in Oakdale.

However, concerns were raised about market saturation, with some council members fearing that the introduction of the new hotel could harm existing establishments. One council member expressed worries that local hotels might struggle to compete, potentially leading to closures and a shift in the community's demographic. "What happens if our current hotels are driven out of business?" they questioned, highlighting fears of increased homelessness if hotels were to convert into shelters.

City Manager Brian addressed these concerns, assuring residents that the city would not allow hotels to become homeless shelters without proper oversight. He emphasized the importance of prudent growth to sustain city services and maintain quality of life. "If we don't grow prudently, then we will see expenditures increase and revenues not keep pace," he warned.

As the council deliberates, the outcome of this proposal could set a significant precedent for Oakdale's future development. The discussions reflect a broader tension between the desire for economic growth and the preservation of the community's identity, leaving residents and officials alike to ponder what kind of city they want Oakdale to become.