City Council debates new tree removal fees and preservation strategies

The Shoreline City Council convened on February 10, 2025, to discuss critical updates regarding tree preservation and associated fees within the city. The meeting focused on the proposed fee structure for tree removal and the implications for housing development and ecological preservation.

The council began by reviewing the fee in lieu of tree replacement, which is paid into the city's tree fund. This fee is intended to cover the costs of planting and maintaining trees for approximately three years if an applicant cannot replant on-site. A proposal by Council Member Ademasu suggested setting the fee at $2,500, with an additional charge of $200 for every inch of tree diameter removed. This proposal aims to balance the need for tree preservation with the realities of housing development.

Councilor Muscovy expressed concerns about the existing fee structure, which he described as prohibitive for individuals looking to build or expand their homes. He argued that high fees could deter development and suggested that a more effective approach would be to implement a tree code that limits tree removal rather than imposing significant fees. Muscovy emphasized the need for a fair system that does not skew incentives against affordable housing.

The discussion also highlighted the current tree removal permit fee of $2.60, which applies only when more than three trees are removed. Council members clarified that there is no fee for cutting down three or fewer trees, provided they are under 24 inches in diameter. The council acknowledged the need for a comprehensive tree ordinance that aligns with the city's preservation goals.

As the meeting progressed, members recognized the urgency of addressing tree preservation amid ongoing development pressures. Councilor Polley noted the potential need to redesign the city logo, which features trees, if current trends continue. The council plans to revisit these discussions and finalize decisions on March 3, 2025, as they seek to establish a balanced approach to tree preservation and housing development in Shoreline.