Scottsdale Council debates $1.6M Old Town parking structure amid public concerns

In a recent Scottsdale City Council meeting held on February 11, 2025, discussions centered around the proposed parking structure in Old Town, which has sparked significant debate among council members and community stakeholders. The council reviewed a design-build pre-construction services contract for the parking structure, estimated at $1,629,000, intended to provide 200 parking spaces across two stories at Brown Avenue, near the historic Adobe Mission Church.

Mayor and council members expressed concerns about the potential impact of the parking structure on the community, particularly regarding the beloved Farmers Market, which has been a staple in the area for 15 years. The Mayor emphasized the need for a more aesthetically pleasing design that would not detract from the historic character of Old Town. She proposed delaying the decision to allow for further stakeholder engagement and to explore alternative locations that might better serve the community without displacing the Farmers Market.

Public comments during the meeting reflected a divided opinion. Some residents, like Dan Isaac, argued against the necessity of the parking structure, citing a lack of evidence for a parking deficit in the area and the potential for the structure to remain underutilized. He urged the council to reconsider the project, suggesting that the funds could be better allocated elsewhere. Conversely, supporters of the parking structure, including local business owners, argued that it is essential for the revitalization of Old Town and that it could be designed to complement the historic architecture of the area.

The council's discussions highlighted the tension between development and preservation in Scottsdale, with some members advocating for immediate action to proceed with the project while others called for a more thoughtful approach that considers the long-term implications for the community. The Mayor's motion to delay the decision for 30 days to gather more information and input from stakeholders was met with mixed reactions, indicating that the future of the parking structure remains uncertain.

As the council navigates these discussions, the outcome will likely shape the character of Old Town Scottsdale and influence community sentiment towards future development projects. The council is expected to reconvene to further evaluate the proposal and consider the feedback from residents and stakeholders.