Newtown plans $128 million sewer plant amid concerns over costs and environmental impact

The Middletown Board of Supervisors convened on December 16, 2024, to discuss significant developments regarding the proposed Newtown wastewater treatment plant and its implications for the community. The meeting focused on the projected costs, regulatory standards, and potential impacts on residents.

The discussion began with an overview of the estimated costs associated with the new treatment facility, which is projected to be approximately $128 million over a 30-year lifecycle. This figure includes both construction and maintenance expenses, which will be distributed among Newtown's 9,000 customers. Concerns were raised about the financial burden this could place on Middletown, especially as Newtown moves towards a more independent wastewater management system.

Supervisors expressed worries about the potential for increased rates for Middletown residents, particularly in light of the broader regional infrastructure needs. It was noted that the Philadelphia Water Department and Bucks County Water and Sewer Authority are also facing significant capital improvement costs, which could lead to rate hikes regardless of Newtown's decisions.

Residents voiced their concerns about environmental impacts, particularly regarding the discharge from the treatment plant into local waterways. Regulatory standards, including Total Maximum Daily Loads (TMDLs), were discussed to assure that any discharge would meet safety criteria. However, some residents remained skeptical about the effectiveness of these regulations in preventing odors and other nuisances associated with wastewater treatment.

Peter Jordan, a resident, raised alarms about the potential for hydrogen sulfide emissions from the plant, citing his extensive background in hazardous materials. He urged the board to form a task force to investigate the potential off-site impacts of the proposed facility and to develop recommendations to mitigate any negative effects.

The meeting also touched on the economic implications of the treatment plant, with residents questioning the projected cost savings for Newtown and how these would affect Middletown's budget and property taxes. Concerns were raised about the accuracy of the projected rate increases and the historical data used to justify the new facility's costs.

As the meeting progressed, it became clear that the proposed treatment plant is a contentious issue, with significant implications for both Newtown and Middletown residents. The board emphasized the importance of ongoing community involvement and pledged to keep the public informed as discussions continue. Further meetings and opportunities for public input are expected as the project moves forward.