The James City County Board of Supervisors held a regular meeting on November 13, 2024, focusing on significant discussions regarding agricultural land use and a special use permit (SUP) application for a renovated barn property.

The meeting began with a public hearing on the Agricultural Forest District (AFD) withdrawal, where speakers emphasized the benefits of the AFD, including reduced government interference and protection against eminent domain. One speaker highlighted the importance of property rights and the freedom to use land without excessive bureaucratic constraints.

Following this, the board opened a public hearing for the SUP case, where Brandon Nice, a local resident and supporter of the project, spoke passionately about the value of land ownership and the importance of allowing property owners to utilize their land as they see fit. He argued that the proposed project aligns with the county's master plan and would enhance the community by providing a venue for events and gatherings.

David Nice, the property owner, detailed the history of the barn renovation, explaining that the project was a labor of love aimed at restoring the property for community use. He addressed concerns about noise and traffic, stating his commitment to mitigating any disturbances for nearby residents. He noted that previous gatherings at the barn had not generated complaints, suggesting that opposition to the SUP may stem from concerns about increased traffic rather than the project itself.

Steve Romeo, a principal with VHB, presented visual evidence of the barn's transformation and underscored that agritourism activities are permitted by right in the area, reinforcing the project's compliance with local zoning regulations.

The meeting concluded with a call for community consideration of the benefits of the project, emphasizing the potential for improved property values and community engagement. The board will continue to review the SUP application and community feedback before making a final decision.