Architects discuss hillside building design while preserving redwood trees

The San Anselmo Planning Commission meeting on December 16, 2024, focused on a proposed two-story building that has raised concerns among residents regarding its height and massing. The discussions highlighted the challenges posed by the site's topography, which has led to a design that some believe resembles a five-story structure from street level.

Commission members expressed their apprehensions about the building's visual impact, questioning whether a more nuanced design could be achieved rather than the current large rectangular shape. The applicant's team explained that the constraints of the hillside made it difficult to alter the building's form significantly without increasing earthwork and potentially harming the health of nearby redwood trees.

One key point of discussion was the possibility of stepping back the second floor to reduce the building's perceived height. However, engineers noted that this would require extensive excavation and could jeopardize the stability of the redwoods, which are considered vital to the site's ecology. The preservation of these trees is a priority, as removing even one could lead to the loss of others.

The applicant also addressed landscaping concerns, explaining that the steepness of the property limits the number of trees that can be planted due to fire safety regulations. While the front of the property will have less landscaping, the majority of the site will remain wooded, ensuring that the health of the surrounding environment is maintained.

As the Planning Commission continues to evaluate the proposal, the discussions reflect a broader commitment to balancing development with environmental preservation, a concern that resonates deeply with the San Anselmo community. The next steps will involve further analysis of the design and its implications for both the neighborhood and the natural landscape.