Officials review Evendale demonstration amid permit controversy and police response questions

In a recent Hamilton County Commissioners Staff Meeting held on February 25, 2025, discussions centered around a complex incident involving a demonstration that raised questions about law enforcement protocols and permit requirements. The meeting highlighted the challenges faced by police during the event, which involved multiple agencies and significant public safety considerations.

The meeting began with a review of the incident, which required the analysis of over 16 hours of body camera footage from local law enforcement. A total of 39 officers from 16 different police departments responded to the situation, underscoring the scale and complexity of the event. Officials emphasized the importance of a thorough investigation, stating that while a quick resolution could be provided, it would not be as comprehensive. This approach aims to ensure that all details are accurately assessed, particularly given the nuances of police communications during the incident.

Commissioner Summer O'Dennis raised concerns regarding the lack of a permit for the demonstration, questioning why the county was not notified. The Mayor of Evendale clarified that no permit was issued and acknowledged that the organizers should have sought one. However, he noted that the primary focus of law enforcement during the event was de-escalation, given the potential for conflict between demonstrators and passing vehicles.

The discussion also touched on the legality of the demonstration itself. Officers determined that the demonstration was lawful based on the participants' adherence to sidewalk regulations, although some individuals briefly stepped off the sidewalk, which could have constituted a minor pedestrian violation. Ultimately, law enforcement opted not to issue citations or make arrests, prioritizing public safety over strict enforcement in a tense environment.

The meeting concluded with a recognition of the need for clearer communication and protocols regarding permits for public demonstrations. As the investigation continues, officials are expected to provide further insights into the incident and its implications for future events in Hamilton County. The discussions reflect ongoing efforts to balance public safety with the rights of individuals to assemble and express their views.