San Francisco Commission Approves Controversial Sculpture Installation at Embarcadero Plaza

The San Francisco City Commission convened on March 3, 2025, to discuss the proposed installation of a controversial sculpture at Embarcadero Plaza. The meeting began with a presentation from city officials, including Miss Riley and Miss Ketchum, who outlined the collaboration with Downtown SF and Rec and Park to bring the sculpture to the city.

The discussion quickly turned to the sculpture's previous proposed location at Union Square, which was deemed unsuitable due to insufficient preparatory studies and concerns about public backlash. Commissioner Hakimi expressed skepticism about the sculpture's ability to attract visitors to Embarcadero, noting that the area is not as severely impacted as Union Square. However, officials emphasized that Embarcadero Plaza also suffers from vacant storefronts and is in need of revitalization.

Concerns about the sculpture's controversial nature were raised by several commissioners, particularly regarding its depiction of a large, naked woman created by a male artist. Commissioner Beltran highlighted the potential for public backlash and suggested consulting the city attorney regarding the commercial implications of showcasing a piece that has been for sale for an extended period.

The commission acknowledged the importance of community feedback, with calls for more extensive public comment on the sculpture's impact. Commissioner Walker supported the idea of using the installation as a platform for dialogue, emphasizing the role of art in fostering community engagement.

The sculpture, weighing approximately 32,000 pounds, will be monitored for structural integrity, especially concerning seismic and wind resilience. The installation is planned for a duration of six months, with the possibility of extension, and will not damage the plaza's surface.

After thorough discussion, the commission moved to approve the installation, with some members abstaining pending further legal advice on the commercial advantages afforded to the artist. The meeting concluded with a commitment to ensure that community voices are heard throughout the process, as the city seeks to revitalize public spaces through art.